Coral Reefs Can Look Alive and Still Be Functionally Dead

1
00:00:02,838 --> 00:00:05,701
A reef can look alive and still be functionally dead.

2
00:00:05,701 --> 00:00:15,438
We're gonna talk about how reef complexity really shows the true health of coral reefs and
why we are losing that structure and why reefs are really in trouble.

3
00:00:15,438 --> 00:00:17,492
We're gonna talk about that on today's episode.

4
00:00:17,492 --> 00:00:26,401
And if you care about staying informed on the ocean every weekday, hit that follow button
right now so you don't miss tomorrow's story.

5
00:00:26,401 --> 00:00:27,231
Here's what happened.

6
00:00:27,231 --> 00:00:28,116
There was a...

7
00:00:28,116 --> 00:00:35,280
recent study in Thailand that looked at the National Reef Assessment and shows that reefs
are losing that structural complexity.

8
00:00:35,280 --> 00:00:38,582
You're probably wondering, Andrew, what in the world does that mean?

9
00:00:38,582 --> 00:00:41,473
When you look at a coral reef, it's not just flat.

10
00:00:41,473 --> 00:00:48,958
It's not just one coral species in a line, and it's just flat all the way across, and you
have all these different species.

11
00:00:48,958 --> 00:00:56,982
A coral reef is made up of a number of different species of corals, whether they're
branching, whether they're flat, whether they're like a boulder type.

12
00:00:56,982 --> 00:00:57,873
It doesn't matter.

13
00:00:57,873 --> 00:01:01,083
It's all these different types and they create this complexity.

14
00:01:01,083 --> 00:01:09,441
It's like a 3D model of just different nooks and crannies that species can hide in so that
they don't get eaten all the time.

15
00:01:09,441 --> 00:01:10,552
They don't get attacked.

16
00:01:10,552 --> 00:01:18,698
You see more Aeos feed from there and they hide their regular bodies because they're so
long and they come out and they start eating animals.

17
00:01:18,698 --> 00:01:25,314
All this complexity really builds into a diverse, structurally ready community.

18
00:01:25,314 --> 00:01:34,400
But even though coral cover may still be present in the reef, it doesn't mean that the
rugosity, meaning the complexity, is still there and still healthy.

19
00:01:34,400 --> 00:01:36,942
It could be declining and that's what they're finding.

20
00:01:36,942 --> 00:01:43,006
Flattened reefs provide less habitat for fish and invertebrates, as I just mentioned,
because of the complexity.

21
00:01:43,006 --> 00:01:49,511
And the structural degradation reduces biodiversity and the ecosystem stability.

22
00:01:49,511 --> 00:01:54,031
As I mentioned, structure matters for a number of different reasons.

23
00:01:54,031 --> 00:01:58,891
You know, you get the structural complexity that supports high fish biomass.

24
00:01:58,891 --> 00:02:04,131
So that means the fish can hide, they can grow bigger, and they can grow fatter,
essentially.

25
00:02:04,131 --> 00:02:12,651
High biomass means you have a lot more species and each and every individual is bigger and
thicker because they can grow up to be bigger.

26
00:02:12,651 --> 00:02:14,011
You know, they can grow up to adults.

27
00:02:14,011 --> 00:02:16,911
They're not just juveniles getting picked off by predators.

28
00:02:16,911 --> 00:02:21,910
And in a structurally complex reef, they have a lot of places to hide around.

29
00:02:21,910 --> 00:02:32,454
I'm not sure if you've ever been diving on a coral reef, but you can see, especially in a
very healthy, 3D enabled, structurally complex reef, have branching corals that allow fish

30
00:02:32,454 --> 00:02:32,815
to hide.

31
00:02:32,815 --> 00:02:36,116
And even if you see them, I can't get my finger in there to grab it.

32
00:02:36,116 --> 00:02:39,997
I can't get my hand in there to grab without hurting myself or scratching myself.

33
00:02:39,997 --> 00:02:43,309
Imagine a fish like I am a scuba diver, which I wouldn't do anyway.

34
00:02:43,309 --> 00:02:47,261
But I, you know, if I'm a scuba diver trying to get a fish, I can scratch my hand.

35
00:02:47,261 --> 00:02:51,106
I can scratch like if I'm wearing gloves, I can scratch those gloves because those

36
00:02:51,106 --> 00:02:57,251
branching corals are sitting there and they're rugged, they're hard, and so you can get
scratched.

37
00:02:57,251 --> 00:03:01,754
Imagine a fish that's trying to attack another invertebrate or fish that's hiding behind
these branched corals.

38
00:03:01,754 --> 00:03:03,055
Imagine them getting scratched.

39
00:03:03,055 --> 00:03:06,408
That puts them vulnerable to their predators because they're injured.

40
00:03:06,408 --> 00:03:07,398
They don't want to get injured.

41
00:03:07,398 --> 00:03:14,734
So a lot of these fish and invertebrates end up being protected by the structural
complexity of the reef.

42
00:03:14,734 --> 00:03:17,378
And I think that's an important aspect to think about.

43
00:03:17,378 --> 00:03:21,380
You know, we talk about coral coverage, you know, from a very basic indicator.

44
00:03:21,380 --> 00:03:26,333
Not that that's not a good indicator, but we see that from a lot of satellite imagery.

45
00:03:26,333 --> 00:03:27,554
We see it from drones.

46
00:03:27,554 --> 00:03:36,839
We see it from aerial photography and aerial surveys, even from scuba diving surveys that
will tow someone across a reef, you know, in the water.

47
00:03:36,839 --> 00:03:41,711
And that person is doing a visual assessment or they're holding a video camera or video
cameras being towed.

48
00:03:41,711 --> 00:03:44,213
It's a very quick survey.

49
00:03:44,213 --> 00:03:47,074
And so although certain species might be

50
00:03:47,147 --> 00:03:55,433
identified, especially when it comes to fish species or invertebrate species, you're not
going to get the full picture of that complexity until you look at that reef.

51
00:03:55,433 --> 00:04:05,820
And so when you see a satellite imagery and you measure coral cover as a percentage, so
it's like, hey, this area is covered by 80 % coral or 60 % coral or 40 % coral, and you're

52
00:04:05,820 --> 00:04:14,826
using that as a health indicator and the only health indicator, that could be a tough
thing because as we see more bleaching, as we see

53
00:04:14,826 --> 00:04:23,028
more things that are damaging coral reefs, overfishing, algae, overgrowth, that structure
is not rebuilding like it used to.

54
00:04:23,028 --> 00:04:32,611
And that structure takes years and decades to create because these corals that are making
the structure, these hard corals, take time to grow.

55
00:04:32,611 --> 00:04:41,443
And although there's ways to make them faster through like electrical pulses and things
like that, naturally, it's a difficult thing for a species to do, especially if it's

56
00:04:41,443 --> 00:04:44,778
getting hit down by storms, which there were more storms because of climate change.

57
00:04:44,778 --> 00:04:58,342
If it's not getting enough uh calcium from the uh whole relationship between the
zooanthellae, the algae that lives within the corals, providing that bicarbonate so that

58
00:04:58,342 --> 00:05:02,303
they can build their skeletal structure and grow their skeletal structure.

59
00:05:02,303 --> 00:05:09,545
If we see too high of temperatures, that zooanthellae get exited quickly, expelled out of
that coral.

60
00:05:09,545 --> 00:05:13,396
And so a coral reef can go bleach over time and then that...

61
00:05:13,396 --> 00:05:23,293
structure doesn't grow and it can get knocked down through storms and if it's not
constantly growing, if it's not healthy, then that can uh be a detriment to the whole

62
00:05:23,293 --> 00:05:24,574
coral reef health.

63
00:05:24,574 --> 00:05:30,778
And so you get less diversity of species, you get less resiliency, which because that's
what diversity provides.

64
00:05:30,778 --> 00:05:34,841
And then that doesn't support a healthy reef.

65
00:05:34,841 --> 00:05:42,146
That predator-prey balance just goes out of whack because once the predators pick off all
the prey, then the predators are going to leave.

66
00:05:42,146 --> 00:05:52,210
and then there's nothing there to stabilize the overgrowth of algae or there's nothing
there to kind of prop up and keep uh species from eating coral.

67
00:05:52,210 --> 00:05:55,471
There's a lot of things that go on within a coral reef.

68
00:05:55,672 --> 00:06:04,035
You have algae overgrowth that can happen at any point in time depending on the right
nutrients and phosphate levels and the right sunlight levels and the right heat.

69
00:06:04,035 --> 00:06:08,011
You can get a huge algal bloom on a reef and it can grow on these corals.

70
00:06:08,011 --> 00:06:13,244
And these corals will get smothered because light won't penetrate the coral skeleton to
get to the zooanthellae.

71
00:06:13,244 --> 00:06:21,989
And then usually what you have is you have these species that will eat the algae off the
coral and keep the coral, like keep the algae down so you keep the coral intact.

72
00:06:21,989 --> 00:06:27,832
But if all those species are picked off by predators because they can't hide in the coral,
those corals are vulnerable.

73
00:06:27,832 --> 00:06:33,825
You're get less of those species, the predators are gonna go and then you're not gonna
have anything to maintain, you know, this coral.

74
00:06:33,825 --> 00:06:35,726
That's just one example of what happens on a coral reef.

75
00:06:35,726 --> 00:06:37,541
It's not the only thing that will...

76
00:06:37,541 --> 00:06:48,094
deter a coral or be detrimental to a coral reef, but it helps it helps a lot and there's a
lot of debate within coral reef science about what is better, you know, like the algae

77
00:06:48,094 --> 00:06:59,018
eaters or the coral eaters and all these kind of things, but you know, it really goes to
looking at how we can maintain these reefs in a healthy thing looking at one indicator and

78
00:06:59,018 --> 00:07:03,063
I've been a scientist that works with indicators a lot and oftentimes

79
00:07:03,063 --> 00:07:09,278
just working with one indicator is not the right indicator to use or it doesn't really
speak to overall health.

80
00:07:09,278 --> 00:07:11,000
It speaks to one aspect of health.

81
00:07:11,000 --> 00:07:14,303
And I'm not saying the scientific community is working off one indicator.

82
00:07:14,303 --> 00:07:25,332
What this story tells us is that we as citizens, as people who listen to uh health of
corals, when we're looking at corals, we have to know that complexity is a big part of

83
00:07:25,332 --> 00:07:27,595
reef health and not just coral cover.

84
00:07:27,595 --> 00:07:27,854
Right?

85
00:07:27,854 --> 00:07:30,605
Because that's what a lot of times, know, journals or

86
00:07:30,605 --> 00:07:31,046
uh...

87
00:07:31,046 --> 00:07:40,307
articles on the on the internet will kinda give will be like all there's more coral cover
here but if it's just flat that is not necessarily saying is going to be healthy

88
00:07:42,146 --> 00:07:48,427
Now, if this is the kind of stuff, you know, the clear ocean breakdown that you find
helpful, please make sure you're following the show.

89
00:07:48,427 --> 00:07:52,478
New episodes are dropping every weekday morning at 5 a.m.

90
00:07:52,478 --> 00:07:53,049
Eastern.

91
00:07:53,049 --> 00:07:56,789
It's something that I'm looking forward to doing and I want you to be a part of it.

92
00:07:57,210 --> 00:08:02,941
So as I said before, flattened reefs weaken coral like coastal storm protection, right?

93
00:08:02,941 --> 00:08:06,872
Like if we don't have, I'm going start that over.

94
00:08:07,972 --> 00:08:12,041
So flattened reefs not only stop corals from growing and

95
00:08:12,041 --> 00:08:17,844
is really bad for coral reef health in general, but it's also weak in storm protection.

96
00:08:17,905 --> 00:08:26,920
Coral reefs are, because of their structure, as waves come over the coral reef, the wave
energy, that force of that energy dissipates.

97
00:08:26,920 --> 00:08:30,763
It gets lower and lower and lower, and once it reaches the shore, you're fine.

98
00:08:30,763 --> 00:08:38,507
So for instance, when the tsunami in 2004 hit the Indian Ocean, and the coastal parts of
the Indian Ocean,

99
00:08:38,507 --> 00:08:50,242
those areas that had intact coral reefs, intact mangroves, intact sea grasses did better
in terms of less damage and less mortality of people than areas that were degradated.

100
00:08:50,782 --> 00:08:52,333
Unfortunately, that's just what happened.

101
00:08:52,333 --> 00:09:00,466
So keeping the complexity of the reefs make better storm protection, coastal storm
protection.

102
00:09:00,466 --> 00:09:07,245
And then of course, if you have a flattened reef, fisheries productivity declines with
habitat loss.

103
00:09:07,245 --> 00:09:14,085
And then of course coral percentage alone is not reliable ecosystem, and it's not a
reliable ecosystem metric.

104
00:09:14,445 --> 00:09:18,325
So reefs can look alive and still be ecologically diminished.

105
00:09:18,325 --> 00:09:22,545
That's the point of this story, of this episode, of this podcast.

106
00:09:22,545 --> 00:09:31,265
You know, it's one of those things where we look, we may look, and people who are not
around coral reefs all the if you're diving or snorkeling on a coral reef, and you're

107
00:09:31,265 --> 00:09:33,579
going from above, say you're snorkeling, and you're...

108
00:09:33,579 --> 00:09:35,400
maybe 10 or 20 feet above a coral reef.

109
00:09:35,400 --> 00:09:38,690
know, obviously people can dive down and look at the complexity there.

110
00:09:38,690 --> 00:09:43,512
Those free divers, those amazing people who can hold their breath for a lot longer and go
down.

111
00:09:43,512 --> 00:09:45,592
Unfortunately, I'm not trained as one of them.

112
00:09:45,592 --> 00:09:49,913
But when you look at it from the top and you see just the coral cover, you could be like,
actually, this is pretty cool.

113
00:09:49,913 --> 00:09:51,494
Like, it looks pretty healthy.

114
00:09:51,494 --> 00:09:53,915
And it might indicate a part of health.

115
00:09:53,915 --> 00:09:55,875
The coral cover still is important.

116
00:09:55,875 --> 00:10:02,177
But the fact that we can't go down and see whether it's three dimensional, whether we see
the branching corals, whether we see

117
00:10:02,177 --> 00:10:12,074
the stony corals that are like in a boulder or that are flat and that provides those
hiding spots for those corals or for those species that are helping those corals, those

118
00:10:12,074 --> 00:10:20,710
fish species, those invertebrate species like the shrimp, the worms, the crabs, all those
things that that make corals really beautiful and diverse.

119
00:10:20,710 --> 00:10:27,905
If you don't have that complexity in those hiding spots, those nooks and crannies, you
don't have a full time healthy reef.

120
00:10:27,905 --> 00:10:31,647
And that is going to degrade faster and easier.

121
00:10:31,777 --> 00:10:33,478
than it would if it was three-dimensional.

122
00:10:33,478 --> 00:10:39,130
So flat reef will be a lot more vulnerable than a 3D complex reef.

123
00:10:39,130 --> 00:10:41,655
So that's why I want to get over on this episode.

124
00:10:41,655 --> 00:10:43,516
I think it's really important that you know that.

125
00:10:43,516 --> 00:10:50,772
And if you want more focused up ocean updates, five days a week, hit follow now and I will
see you tomorrow.

126
00:10:50,772 --> 00:10:52,113
Happy conservation.