Ocean Fish Populations at Risk: How WTO Subsidies Still Fuel Overfishing

1
00:00:09,942 --> 00:00:12,119
A new World Trade Ocean.

2
00:00:17,422 --> 00:00:23,602
A new World Trade Organization fishery subsidies was released earlier last or later last
year in 2025.

3
00:00:23,602 --> 00:00:33,062
And it talks about subsidies, fishery subsidies, and it's supposed to help with
transparency, help with controlling the amount of subsidies that are given in the

4
00:00:33,062 --> 00:00:34,802
fisheries industry.

5
00:00:34,822 --> 00:00:36,862
But the problem is the fight is not over.

6
00:00:36,862 --> 00:00:39,202
We are still funding the problem.

7
00:00:39,202 --> 00:00:46,382
And if you like this episode of the How to Protect the Ocean podcast, consider following
this show so you get an ocean news.

8
00:00:46,382 --> 00:00:47,782
every weekday.

9
00:00:47,782 --> 00:00:51,582
So just hit that follow button right now so you don't miss tomorrow's story.

10
00:00:51,642 --> 00:00:54,382
All right, let's talk about what happened in 2022.

11
00:00:54,382 --> 00:01:00,022
The World Trade Organization adopted the first phase of a fisheries subsidies agreement.

12
00:01:00,022 --> 00:01:04,422
And this in 2025, it adopted the second phase, which was kind of cool.

13
00:01:04,422 --> 00:01:12,942
The agreements target subsidies and linked to illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing,
often called IUU fishing.

14
00:01:12,942 --> 00:01:15,430
That's what I'll refer to it the rest of this episode.

15
00:01:15,552 --> 00:01:27,027
It provides subsidies for vessels engaging in IUU activities and for fishing of over stock
fish or over stocks, over fish stocks under certain conditions.

16
00:01:27,027 --> 00:01:33,390
However, it does not yet fully address subsidies that drive over capacity and fleet
expansion.

17
00:01:33,390 --> 00:01:36,351
So there's still some problems with this fisheries.

18
00:01:36,351 --> 00:01:37,202
It's a great start.

19
00:01:37,202 --> 00:01:37,852
Don't get me wrong.

20
00:01:37,852 --> 00:01:43,284
It is a fantastic start, but we still have problems with this type of subsidy.

21
00:01:43,395 --> 00:01:46,036
We can still poke holes in it, let's just say.

22
00:01:46,036 --> 00:01:51,257
Now what the data shows, and the Pew Charitable Trust shows that the agreement is historic
but incomplete.

23
00:01:51,357 --> 00:01:58,799
Most major subsidy categories that encourage overfishing remain largely untouched.

24
00:01:58,799 --> 00:02:05,500
So further negotiation of these phases are required to close all these different types of
loopholes.

25
00:02:05,500 --> 00:02:12,802
So the government's provided, in a Nature study in 2019, government's provided an
estimated 35

26
00:02:12,802 --> 00:02:16,264
billion USD per year in fishery subsidies globally.

27
00:02:16,264 --> 00:02:21,367
Roughly two thirds of that total is considered capacity enhancing or harmful.

28
00:02:21,367 --> 00:02:23,609
We'll talk about that in just a moment.

29
00:02:23,609 --> 00:02:30,513
So fuel subsidies are among the most significant contributors to overfishing pressure.

30
00:02:30,653 --> 00:02:33,215
And again, we're gonna get into that in a minute.

31
00:02:33,215 --> 00:02:38,548
So from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, we saw that fisheries
support

32
00:02:39,150 --> 00:02:42,151
Fisheries support remains uneven across countries.

33
00:02:42,151 --> 00:02:45,132
So there's a problem with equity around there.

34
00:02:45,273 --> 00:02:53,736
The reform progress is inconsistent and transparency is reporting subsidy flows that still
varies widely.

35
00:02:53,916 --> 00:02:56,957
So here's the problem with these subsidies, right?

36
00:02:57,118 --> 00:03:04,080
When you have these capacity enhancing subsidies, it allows fleets to fish farther.

37
00:03:04,080 --> 00:03:08,322
basically what it's doing is it gives, it'll give like a

38
00:03:08,334 --> 00:03:10,915
tax write-offs or write-offs on gas.

39
00:03:10,915 --> 00:03:14,998
It'll allow for, you know, boats, more boats to go further.

40
00:03:14,998 --> 00:03:18,490
And so when you go further, you start going into different regions.

41
00:03:18,490 --> 00:03:21,741
You start going further away and you start fishing further away.

42
00:03:21,741 --> 00:03:24,828
So there may not be a lot of fish along your coastline, right?

43
00:03:24,828 --> 00:03:27,885
Or anywhere within your nation's exclusive economic zone.

44
00:03:27,885 --> 00:03:29,756
But then all of sudden you can go out those boundaries.

45
00:03:29,756 --> 00:03:31,847
You can go to the high seas, right?

46
00:03:31,847 --> 00:03:35,969
If your boat is big enough and it's safe to go and you have enough fuel to go, you'll go
there.

47
00:03:35,969 --> 00:03:37,900
You might go to a different country

48
00:03:37,952 --> 00:03:39,682
and fish their stocks.

49
00:03:39,683 --> 00:03:41,663
Whether you're allowed or not, that's another case.

50
00:03:41,663 --> 00:03:44,885
But in these regions, sometimes the borders overlap.

51
00:03:44,885 --> 00:03:48,846
And so you can go into a different country that may not have the right expansion.

52
00:03:48,846 --> 00:03:51,998
As I said, the equity is not equal.

53
00:03:51,998 --> 00:03:53,148
It's not there.

54
00:03:53,188 --> 00:04:03,522
So some countries that can't afford to pay their fishers to go further or to be able to
fish even within their own boundaries, they lose out because others are coming over

55
00:04:03,522 --> 00:04:05,813
because those countries have more money.

56
00:04:05,813 --> 00:04:09,295
and the equity, the subsidy equity is just not there.

57
00:04:09,876 --> 00:04:18,541
So industrial fleets can even out-compete small-scale fishers like artisanal fishers,
which also increases inequity.

58
00:04:18,922 --> 00:04:27,668
So you have all these major industrial fleets that go around, these large trawlers, and
they even have processing plants on the trawlers, and they can go around and they can fish

59
00:04:27,668 --> 00:04:29,009
as many as they want.

60
00:04:29,009 --> 00:04:35,313
Because they have more fuel, they have bigger ships, they can travel longer, and they can
actually process right on the boat.

61
00:04:35,777 --> 00:04:39,100
They can even store all the processed fish right on the boat.

62
00:04:39,621 --> 00:04:47,568
these subsidies allow for these industrial fishers to just uh profit over these artisanal
fishers, over these small-scale fisheries.

63
00:04:48,389 --> 00:04:53,354
And subsidies distort the market signal, so masking the true ecological cost of fishing.

64
00:04:53,354 --> 00:05:01,701
So essentially, if you start to subsidize boats and subsidize fishers to go out further,
to go out longer, to have bigger boats so they can go out further.

65
00:05:02,123 --> 00:05:05,274
then they'll come back with a lot of fish and they'll be like, you know what?

66
00:05:05,274 --> 00:05:09,135
The fisheries economy is doing really well because they're catching more fish.

67
00:05:09,135 --> 00:05:15,516
But over the long run, you have all these uh problems ecologically.

68
00:05:16,057 --> 00:05:18,097
The fishery stocks will collapse.

69
00:05:18,097 --> 00:05:19,318
They're overfished.

70
00:05:19,318 --> 00:05:29,640
The food web will collapse or it'll change because the prey that was originally caught by
those uh fish species, now overfished, are just gonna blossom.

71
00:05:29,640 --> 00:05:30,707
They're gonna go out of control.

72
00:05:30,707 --> 00:05:32,046
It's gonna change.

73
00:05:32,046 --> 00:05:42,346
the way the food web is and it you know it food webs change it happens but when humans
cause that change we're not ready for the consequences of that change the ocean will will

74
00:05:42,346 --> 00:05:53,126
be there and they'll survive okay but as of from a fisheries perspective we start to fish
smaller pelagic fish and they're not at they're not as as economical it takes longer to

75
00:05:53,126 --> 00:05:57,222
catch them and stuff and then we'll start fishing down the food chain and that's not good

76
00:05:57,688 --> 00:06:05,381
So if governments pay to expand fleets while claiming to rebuild stocks, policy and
science are moving in opposite directions.

77
00:06:05,422 --> 00:06:14,045
So it's just like yesterday's episode when we talked about political will just being like,
you know what, we're just going to subsidize this fishery so that you can go out there and

78
00:06:14,045 --> 00:06:16,847
we can make it look like we actually have a lot of fish.

79
00:06:16,847 --> 00:06:19,428
That's only gonna last for a certain amount of time.

80
00:06:19,728 --> 00:06:22,449
And depending on the country, some countries may not care.

81
00:06:22,721 --> 00:06:26,422
We know certainly there's certain administrations that really just don't care.

82
00:06:26,422 --> 00:06:29,693
Even in Canada here where we talk about fisheries and fisheries is a big part.

83
00:06:29,693 --> 00:06:31,674
We have the longest coastline in the world.

84
00:06:31,674 --> 00:06:45,288
A lot of the times we leave our fishing communities out to dry when it comes to managing
fisheries because we previously over fish species to continue to be fished.

85
00:06:45,288 --> 00:06:49,345
We bow to the political will of the stakeholders even though

86
00:06:49,345 --> 00:06:53,147
we're not looking out for the small fishing communities.

87
00:06:54,489 --> 00:06:57,510
So this is the kind of breakdown you enjoy to hear.

88
00:06:57,510 --> 00:07:02,625
Obviously it's not good news, but you enjoy hearing because it's stuff that you don't hear
each and every day.

89
00:07:02,625 --> 00:07:04,845
I just want you to follow the show.

90
00:07:04,845 --> 00:07:11,040
Click that follow button to make sure that you don't miss any episode every weekday
morning that we put it out 5 a.m.

91
00:07:11,040 --> 00:07:11,920
Eastern.

92
00:07:11,920 --> 00:07:19,191
Fridays is an interview episode, but all these during the week, like Monday to Thursday,
is all solo ocean news episodes.

93
00:07:19,191 --> 00:07:21,943
trying to keep you up to date on what's happening around the ocean.

94
00:07:21,943 --> 00:07:32,312
So the overall picture, the bigger picture in this story today, in this episode, is that
fisheries populations cannot fully recover if fishing pressures artificially propped up by

95
00:07:32,312 --> 00:07:32,953
public money.

96
00:07:32,953 --> 00:07:34,103
This is taxpayer money.

97
00:07:34,103 --> 00:07:35,985
It's the government providing this money.

98
00:07:35,985 --> 00:07:38,657
It has to come from somewhere, it comes from the people.

99
00:07:38,657 --> 00:07:45,723
And of course, climate change is already reducing ocean productivity in many of these
regions, which exacerbates the problem.

100
00:07:45,883 --> 00:07:48,255
You start to increase fishing pressure,

101
00:07:48,290 --> 00:07:57,573
that fisheries goes down, it has a tough time to recover because of climate change and
just continues to go down and down or it just doesn't never reaches the levels that it

102
00:07:57,573 --> 00:07:58,814
once was.

103
00:08:00,074 --> 00:08:05,596
Continuing to finance over capacity increases risk of the stock collapse.

104
00:08:05,596 --> 00:08:12,899
We saw this over and over again in the 70s, 80s and early 90s when the cod fishery
collapsed.

105
00:08:13,139 --> 00:08:15,520
know, scientists saw the trends.

106
00:08:15,520 --> 00:08:18,261
They would tell the minister,

107
00:08:18,379 --> 00:08:19,209
in Canada.

108
00:08:19,209 --> 00:08:22,071
The minister ignored it because the stakeholders still wanted to fish.

109
00:08:22,071 --> 00:08:25,912
They would subsidize the fishing fleet to make sure they could go out and continue to
fish.

110
00:08:25,912 --> 00:08:29,353
Cod Halibut had it basically collapsed.

111
00:08:30,054 --> 00:08:32,715
And it hasn't really fully recovered.

112
00:08:32,735 --> 00:08:33,829
It still hasn't.

113
00:08:33,829 --> 00:08:36,277
30 years later, it still hasn't fully recovered.

114
00:08:36,277 --> 00:08:39,398
Yeah, it's starting to recover, but we haven't seen full recovery.

115
00:08:39,398 --> 00:08:42,829
And we continue to bow to stakeholders to say, you know what?

116
00:08:42,829 --> 00:08:44,890
Yeah, if you want to fish further offshore, you can do it.

117
00:08:44,890 --> 00:08:46,121
Every country does it.

118
00:08:46,121 --> 00:08:47,271
Every country.

119
00:08:49,195 --> 00:08:58,279
Now, the next negotiation phase of the World Trade Organization will determine whether
real reform happens or whether harmful subsidies remain protected.

120
00:08:58,279 --> 00:09:05,612
And look, we have seen how these uh large negotiation meetings happen, like how they work.

121
00:09:05,692 --> 00:09:07,573
We've seen it in the plastic treaty.

122
00:09:07,573 --> 00:09:09,814
We've seen it in the climate treaty.

123
00:09:09,814 --> 00:09:18,445
know, oil and gas and fisheries lobbyists will be sent out to really start to uh mold the
future.

124
00:09:18,445 --> 00:09:25,271
to their will so they can continue to pollute with CO2 and harmful greenhouse gases.

125
00:09:25,271 --> 00:09:32,918
They can continue to make money hand over fist without worrying about local communities,
without worrying about the environment.

126
00:09:33,199 --> 00:09:39,685
so, know, fossil fuel companies, fishing company, large industrial fishing companies, all
they care about is profit.

127
00:09:39,685 --> 00:09:40,696
That's all they care about.

128
00:09:40,696 --> 00:09:42,728
They don't care about you, they don't care about the people.

129
00:09:42,728 --> 00:09:44,679
All they care about is profit.

130
00:09:45,229 --> 00:09:52,909
And when you have a situation where you have these meetings, is important that nonprofit
organizations send all their people.

131
00:09:52,909 --> 00:10:03,529
It is important that we send all our support so that we want better managed oceans and
less subsidy so we can get a fair World Trade Organization fishery subsidies document and

132
00:10:03,529 --> 00:10:13,989
policy so that we can reduce IEU fishing and eventually eliminate IEU fishing, which comes
out with a lot of other things that come with that, not only in the environment, but human

133
00:10:13,989 --> 00:10:14,561
rights.

134
00:10:14,561 --> 00:10:17,224
and we reduce and eliminate fishery slaves.

135
00:10:18,765 --> 00:10:25,809
So the big question here is can we rebuild fish populations while continuing to subsidize
fleet expansion?

136
00:10:25,809 --> 00:10:28,891
And I think you can, but you have to do it very carefully.

137
00:10:29,051 --> 00:10:37,275
I'm not an economist, so I don't know exactly how, but I feel like there's a middle ground
here where you're not trying to increase the fishing pressure.

138
00:10:37,736 --> 00:10:40,548
And I think the problem is you have to follow the science.

139
00:10:40,548 --> 00:10:43,409
The subsidies should match what the science says.

140
00:10:43,409 --> 00:10:46,631
If the quota has to go down, the subsidies shouldn't go out.

141
00:10:47,083 --> 00:10:50,115
If the quota can come up, maybe the subsidies go out.

142
00:10:50,296 --> 00:10:52,998
But it has to be fully managed and monitored.

143
00:10:52,998 --> 00:10:58,663
Until harmful subsidies are fully removed, we are still paying to deplete the ocean.

144
00:10:58,663 --> 00:11:00,604
That's really what it comes down to.

145
00:11:00,604 --> 00:11:01,835
I'd love to hear your thoughts.

146
00:11:01,835 --> 00:11:04,648
Go to speakupforblue.com forward slash feedback.

147
00:11:04,648 --> 00:11:08,931
You can either voice your thoughts by leaving a voicemail or write it out, text it out.

148
00:11:08,931 --> 00:11:10,893
Love to hear what you have to say.

149
00:11:10,893 --> 00:11:16,425
And of course, follow this podcast if you want to hear the latest and greatest of ocean
news.

150
00:11:16,425 --> 00:11:19,688
each and every weekday, 5am Eastern.

151
00:11:19,688 --> 00:11:23,130
And thank you for joining me on today's episode of how to protect the ocean podcast.

152
00:11:23,130 --> 00:11:24,851
I am your host, Angelo and have a great day.

153
00:11:24,851 --> 00:11:27,623
We'll talk to you next time and happy conservation.